Skip to content
The Mormon DilemmaChrist, Scripture & the Restoration

Find a passage or a question

Search the book

Search the full text of the chapters and source appendices. Enter at least two characters.

Contents
Sources & editions ↗
Text size
Free PDF & EPUB Read offline or on Kindle

Sources & reading aids4 min read

A quick guide

Begin with the passages themselves. Read the complete units in the cited-passages appendix, including the surrounding argument. The short answers below summarize the book's conclusions; the chapters supply the evidence and meet the strongest replies.

Question The argument Where to read
Who is Jesus? The Word who was with God and was God became flesh. He creates, sustains, dies for sinners and rises bodily. These affirmations are shared in substantial part; the disagreement concerns His relation to everything else. Chapters 1-2; John 1:1-3, 14; Colossians 1:15-18; Hebrews 1:1-12.
Does all things mean only organized things? That reading can be proposed, but the exception for uncreated intelligence comes from the later revelation. It is not an exception stated by John or Paul. The chapter argues the cumulative Creator/creature distinction rather than resting on one word. Chapter 2; Acts 17:24-29; Doctrine and Covenants 93:29; Abraham 3:18-19.
Can people become gods by grace? Sharing Christ's life and glory does not erase the difference between the eternal Maker and His creatures. Biblical adoption and the later account of beings with an uncreated core require comparison, even when both use the language of grace. Chapters 2 and 8; Isaiah 40:25-26; Revelation 5:13; Doctrine and Covenants 132:20.
Does a change in wording disprove a scripture? No. Ask what changed, which edition shows it and whether the teaching changed. The same standard applies to both books. Chapter 3; Jeremiah 36:32; the material-changes table.
Was the apostolic gospel lost before our surviving copies? That possibility cannot be settled from manuscript silence alone. Early Christian writings preserve the apostolic witness within the proposed period of loss. The particular disagreements examined here concern words the church still receives in its Bible. Chapter 3; John 20:31; the early-Christian extracts.
What about the Book of Mormon's witnesses? Hear their full claims, including the Three's voice declaring the translation true. Emma Smith described the dictation at close range and Martin Harris the weight of the plates, yet no witness saw the words Joseph said he received. Their testimony points to the book; its message must still be tested. Its English Bible passages and the explanations of Latter-day Saint scholars can be examined directly. Chapter 4; the two witness statements; Galatians 1:6-9.
How should a prophet be tested? Christ is the measure. The messenger's claim cannot establish a different God or gospel. The founding claims and later teachings must face the earlier revelation they profess to restore. Chapter 5; Deuteronomy 13:1-5; Galatians 1:6-9.
Does the church's handling of money bear on its claims? The size of its investments is not the argument. A 2023 federal order, settled without admission or denial, found that the church's investment manager filed misstated reports in other entities' names to prevent public disclosure of the church's holdings, with the approval of the church's senior leadership. Scripture and the church's own Articles of Faith require honest dealing before men. No money redeems; Christ became poor for sinners. Chapter 6; 2 Corinthians 8:9, 18-21; Articles of Faith 12-13; 1 Peter 1:18-19; the public-records appendix.
What if I have received a spiritual witness? Do not pretend the experience did not happen. Distinguish it from its interpretation and test the message it is asked to establish. Christians' convictions face the same test. Chapter 7; 1 John 1:1-3; 2:20-27; 4:1-6.
Does grace remove the need to obey? No. Living faith bears works, while works do not purchase justification. Christ's offering is the ground of acceptance; the new life He gives produces obedience. Chapter 8; Romans 4:1-12; James 2:14-26; Ephesians 2:8-10.
Can I know I have eternal life? John directs believers to God's testimony concerning His Son. The church also speaks of knowing eternal life; the comparison concerns the ground and promised content of that assurance. Chapter 8; 1 John 5:9-13; John 5:24; Doctrine and Covenants 131:5.

The church's introduction presents Mormon as an ancient prophet-historian who abridged other prophets' writings. It says that he passed his account to his son Moroni. When this book names Mormon as a speaker, it means that figure; the Book of Mormon means the scripture as a whole.

The Bible is the earlier scripture the church receives as God's word. The Book of Mormon is the additional record whose claim to confirm and restore that witness the book examines. The Doctrine and Covenants collects revelations and instructions associated with the Restoration. The Pearl of Great Price includes Abraham, Joseph Smith's history and the Articles of Faith among its works. These four standard works have a different standing from an official manual, a conference sermon or an apologist's argument. The notes identify which kind of source is being used.

If a quotation or account of the church's teaching is wrong, correct it from the named source. If an argument is difficult, keep it in view and pursue it. The purpose is to know the truth and receive the life God gives in His Son.