Skip to content
The Mormon DilemmaChrist, Scripture & the Restoration

Find a passage or a question

Search the book

Search the full text of the chapters and source appendices. Enter at least two characters.

Contents
Sources & editions ↗
Text size
Free PDF & EPUB Read offline or on Kindle

Chapter 0613 min read

Honest things in the sight of men

In this reading

When the apostle Paul administered a gift from the churches, he took care over how it was handled. He did not carry it alone. With it travelled a brother “chosen of the churches to travel with us with this grace”, and Paul gave his reason: “Avoiding this, that no man should blame us in this abundance which is administered by us: Providing for honest things, not only in the sight of the Lord, but also in the sight of men.”[1] Paul knew that a large gift could bring suspicion on those who handled it, and he met that danger with openness. A church that claims to restore the church of the apostles invites comparison with the apostles' conduct, and the handling of money is one place where that conduct can be examined plainly.

The findings of the United States Securities and Exchange Commission in 2023 describe the opposite course. For almost twenty years, the Commission found, the investment manager of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints filed required reports in the names of other entities, created to prevent public disclosure of the church's holdings, and those reports misstated who controlled the investments. It found that the church's senior leadership, which it defines as the First Presidency and the Presiding Bishopric, approved the approach and its expansion. The church settled the case without admitting or denying the findings.[2] The size of the church's investments is not the charge here. The charge concerns honest dealing, which the church's own Articles of Faith confess as a duty. Beneath it lies a question for every reader: what money can and cannot do before God. No one is redeemed with silver and gold, but with the precious blood of Christ.[3]

What the Commission found

Folders and a magnifying glass on a desk.
Illustration

The order is a settlement, and its limits belong beside its findings. The church and its investment manager, Ensign Peak Advisors, consented to it “without admitting or denying the findings herein”, admitting only the Commission's jurisdiction over them and the subject matter of the proceedings. The order states that its findings bind no other person or entity in that or any other proceeding.[4] What follows are the Commission's findings, which the church neither admitted nor denied.

Ensign Peak was created in 1997 to manage what the church calls its reserves. The order says that these include securities bought with “excess tithing”, income and returns generated by Ensign Peak, and the assets of the church's other integrated auxiliaries.[5] Federal law requires a manager with investment discretion over at least $100 million in listed securities to report them every quarter, and those reports are public. By at least 1998 Ensign Peak's senior managers knew of the requirement and had told the church's senior leadership.[6]

The order then states the reason for what followed: “The Church was concerned that disclosure of the assets in the name of Ensign Peak, a known Church affiliate, would lead to negative consequences in light of the size of the Church’s portfolio.” Ensign Peak could not adopt its plan without the First Presidency's approval, and the church approved it.[7] Beginning in 2001, the church and Ensign Peak created thirteen entities, which the order calls limited liability corporations, “for the sole purpose of filing Forms 13F and preventing public disclosure by Ensign Peak of the Church’s equity securities holdings.” The entities were given addresses in other states, where they did no business beyond receiving mail. In 2005 the church learned that the public might link the first entity to it, because the person signing its reports was listed in a public directory as a church employee. The senior leadership then approved a new reporting entity, to be created with “better care being taken to ensure that neither the ‘Street’ nor the media [could] connect the new entity to Ensign Peak.” It approved further entities in 2011 and 2015.[8]

The reports filed in these entities' names said that each entity had sole investment and voting discretion over the securities it listed. The Commission found that Ensign Peak “at all times retained discretion over all investment decisions.” The order says that the church and Ensign Peak “understood that Ensign Peak continued to make investment and voting decisions relating to the portfolio, and that the LLC Structure was created for the sole purpose of filing Forms 13F.” The business managers who signed the reports were given too little information to make the representations they signed. The order adds that Ensign Peak could not file in its own name without the unanimous approval of the church's senior leadership.[9]

The church's own auditors reviewed the arrangement in 2014 and again in 2017. They did not recommend specific changes, but in discussions with Ensign Peak's senior management they “highlighted the risk that the SEC might disagree with the approach.” In May 2018 a public website reported that entities apparently tied to the church had filed reports showing about $32 billion of holdings. Two of the business managers then resigned, “voicing concerns about what they had been asked to do”, and two others were assigned in their place. On 14 February 2020 Ensign Peak filed a single report in its own name for the last quarter of 2019. It disclosed 1,659 securities worth about $37.8 billion.[10]

The Commission found that Ensign Peak violated the securities reporting law and that the church caused those violations. It ordered both to cease and desist, and it imposed civil penalties of $4 million on Ensign Peak and $1 million on the church.[11]

What the order does not show

A magnifying glass at the edge of a ledger.
Illustration

The order is narrow, and it should be kept narrow. It is a civil settlement about securities reports. It makes no finding of theft or of tax fraud. Apart from saying that the reserves include securities bought with excess tithing, it says nothing about how tithing is spent, and it does not measure the church's charity. It gives no figure for the church's total wealth, income or spending.

Nor would the absence of an annual information return prove wrongdoing by itself. American tax law excuses churches, and some organizations affiliated with churches, from the annual information return that most charities must file. That exception did not remove the separate duty to report securities, which is the duty the order concerns.[12]

Ensign Peak now reports in its own name. Its filing for the quarter that ended on 30 September 2026 lists 1,709 entries of reportable securities with a total value of $60,611,728,144, about $60.61 billion.[13] That figure is easily misused. It covers the listed securities the form requires, not everything the church owns. It is not the church's total wealth, reserves, income or spending, and the Commission's acceptance of a filing does not certify that the filing is accurate. This book draws no argument from the size of the number.

The standard

A balance scale beside an open Bible.
Illustration

Paul's care with the gift was not a point of etiquette. He was a man who knew that God sees, and so he wanted his handling of other people's gifts to bear inspection by men as well.

The church confesses the same standard in its own scripture. The twelfth Article of Faith says, “We believe in being subject to kings, presidents, rulers, and magistrates, in obeying, honoring, and sustaining the law.” The thirteenth begins, “We believe in being honest, true, chaste, benevolent, virtuous, and in doing good to all men”.[14] Both were first printed in 1842, and both stand in the Pearl of Great Price today.

Measured by either standard, the conduct the order describes fails. A report that names an entity as the sole manager of investments it never managed is not honest. The Commission found that the reports said exactly that, and that the church understood who was making the decisions. The entity approved in 2005 was to be created so that neither the “Street” nor the media could connect it to Ensign Peak. An arrangement designed that way was designed so that the filings would not be traced to the church. According to the order, the church's senior leadership approved the approach and approved its expansion. It continued after the church's auditors had raised the risk that the Commission might disagree, and after two of those asked to sign had resigned with concerns.

The strongest case on the other side

Two chairs facing a table with an open ledger.
Illustration

A thoughtful Latter-day Saint can answer with a serious case, and it should be heard as fully as the order allows. What follows is not the church's own statement. The church's own account of these events remains an open question, which this chapter does not examine. This is the case a faithful member could build from the order itself.

The order finds no theft, and it makes no charge about how tithing was spent; the money remained invested for the church. Ensign Peak charges the church no management fees, and the order notes that it is exempt from registering as an investment adviser because it is a charitable organization advising only charitable organizations. The law in question governs reports, and the penalties were civil. The church did not admit the findings. The order itself records a reason for confidentiality: the church feared negative consequences if a large portfolio were disclosed, and a prudent steward may keep a reserve quiet. The church's own auditors did not recommend specific changes. And Ensign Peak reported in its own name from February 2020, three years before the order.[15]

Much of this is true, and this book grants it. The order finds no theft, and this book alleges none. A reserve is not a sin, and its size is not an argument. The penalties were civil, the findings were neither admitted nor denied, and the reporting was corrected before the order.

But the defense explains a reason; it does not change the act. Like Paul's, the concern the order reports arose from abundance: the church feared negative consequences in light of the size of its portfolio. Paul answered the danger of abundance with more light, sending with the gift a brother chosen by the churches. The arrangement the order describes answered its concern with less light: entities with distant addresses, reports that credited the investments to entities that did not manage them, and signers who could not know whether what they signed was true. Keeping one's affairs private can be honest. Telling the public what is not so is not. The auditors' warning does not show that anyone believed the arrangement unlawful. It shows that the risk was raised inside the church, and that the arrangement went on. The church chose to settle, and the findings stand as the Commission's findings. This book treats them as findings, not admissions, and asks what they describe.

Why it matters before God

Bread and a clay cup beside a notebook.
Illustration

This is not the gravest question in this book. A church could keep perfect accounts and still preach another gospel, and a church that preaches the true gospel can still sin with its money. Christians have no ground for boasting here. Second Corinthians 8:21 judges every church that handles gifts, including the churches of this book's readers and of its author, and every Christian who handles money that belongs to others.

But the question bears on the claim this book has been testing. The church claims to restore the church the apostles led. Paul's handling of the gift shows what apostolic authority looked like when it held other people's money: it accepted scrutiny, providing for honest things in the sight of the Lord and of men. When a church, through its senior leadership, approves filing in other names, understands that the named entities make no investment decisions, and keeps that arrangement for almost twenty years where the law requires disclosure, the conduct is not apostolic, whatever the motive. The motive is God's to judge. The deeds can be weighed, and they are set out in a public order that the church chose to settle.

Many Latter-day Saints give faithfully, often at real cost, out of love for God. That devotion is real, and nothing here mocks it. The question is not the sincerity of those who give. It is the honesty owed to them, and to everyone else, by those who administer what they give.

The riches of Christ

Bread and water in a room lit by dawn.
Illustration

Paul grounds giving in Christ. In the same chapter, before he speaks of honest handling, he writes: “For ye know the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, that, though he was rich, yet for your sakes he became poor, that ye through his poverty might be rich.”[16] The Son of God, through whom all things were made, became poor to make sinners rich in Him. Christian giving answers that grace. It does not purchase it.

No reserve, however large, and no gift, however faithful, can pay for one sin. Peter writes, “ye were not redeemed with corruptible things, as silver and gold, from your vain conversation received by tradition from your fathers; But with the precious blood of Christ, as of a lamb without blemish and without spot”.[3] Paul handled the gift with care because he served a greater treasure: the gospel of a Savior who gives Himself freely to all who come to Him.

Hold every church, and every Christian, to the apostles' standard: honest things, in the sight of the Lord and in the sight of men. Then do not look to any church's reserves, or to your own record of giving, for what only Christ can give. He became poor for sinners, and through His poverty all who trust Him are made rich.


Source notes

  1. 2 Corinthians 8:18-21, King James Version.Read the passages2 Corinthians 8 ↩︎

  2. Securities and Exchange Commission, In the Matter of Ensign Peak Advisors, Inc., and The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Exchange Act Release No. 96951, Administrative Proceeding File No. 3-21306 (21 February 2023), §II, p. 1; Summary and ¶1, p. 2; ¶8, p. 3; ¶¶9-16, p. 4. The paragraphs this chapter quotes are printed complete in the public-records appendix.Read the passagesOrder of 21 February 2023, Exchange Act Release No. 96951Section II (p. 1)Summary (p. 2)Paragraph 1 (p. 2)Paragraph 8 (p. 3)Paragraph 11 (p. 4) ↩︎

  3. 1 Peter 1:18-19, King James Version.Read the passages1 Peter 1 ↩︎ ↩︎

  4. SEC order, §II, p. 1; p. 2, n. 1.Read the passagesOrder of 21 February 2023, Exchange Act Release No. 96951Section II (p. 1)Footnote 1 (p. 2) ↩︎

  5. SEC order, ¶¶2-3, pp. 2-3. The order names the sources of the reserves. It gives no annual tithing amount and no current total.Read the passagesOrder of 21 February 2023, Exchange Act Release No. 96951Paragraph 3 (p. 3) ↩︎

  6. SEC order, ¶4 and ¶7, p. 3.Read the passagesOrder of 21 February 2023, Exchange Act Release No. 96951 ↩︎

  7. SEC order, ¶8, p. 3, with the Summary, p. 2.Read the passagesOrder of 21 February 2023, Exchange Act Release No. 96951Summary (p. 2)Paragraph 8 (p. 3) ↩︎

  8. SEC order, Summary, p. 2; ¶¶9-16, p. 4; ¶23, p. 5. The first entity dates from 2001. The order counts thirteen in all, twelve of them similar “Clone LLCs”. Paragraph 11 does not name the document whose words it quotes.Read the passagesOrder of 21 February 2023, Exchange Act Release No. 96951Summary (p. 2)Paragraph 11 (p. 4) ↩︎

  9. SEC order, Summary, p. 2; ¶¶27-28 and 30, p. 6; ¶31, pp. 6-7. Paragraph 30 is printed complete in the public-records appendix.Read the passagesOrder of 21 February 2023, Exchange Act Release No. 96951Summary (p. 2)Paragraph 30 (p. 6) ↩︎

  10. SEC order, ¶¶32-35, p. 7.Read the passagesOrder of 21 February 2023, Exchange Act Release No. 96951Paragraph 32 (p. 7)Paragraph 34 (p. 7) ↩︎

  11. SEC order, ¶¶36-37, p. 7; §IV.A-D, p. 8. The order required payment within ten days; no record of payment is examined here.Read the passagesOrder of 21 February 2023, Exchange Act Release No. 96951 ↩︎

  12. Internal Revenue Service, “Filing Requirements for churches and religious organizations,” retained 16 November 2026. The exception concerns the annual information return. It does not settle the obligations of any particular entity. ↩︎

  13. Ensign Peak Advisors, Inc, Form 13F-HR, accession 0001454984-26-000011, signed and filed 12 November 2026, for the period ending 30 September 2026: summary page, 1,709 table entries, total value 60611728144 dollars. SEC Division of Investment Management staff, “Frequently Asked Questions About Form 13F,” updated 6 March 2026, Question 36 (values reported to the nearest dollar since 3 January 2023) and Question 30 (an acceptance message does not address a filing's accuracy). The SEC order, ¶¶4-5, p. 3, describes the securities the form covers. The values are reported by the filer; the separate holdings table was not summed for this book.Read the passagesOrder of 21 February 2023, Exchange Act Release No. 96951Form 13F-HR filed 12 November 2026 ↩︎

  14. Articles of Faith 1:12-13, current official text, quoted briefly. First printed in “Church History,” Times and Seasons 3, no. 9 (1 March 1842), p. 710, where Article 12 reads “honoring and sustaining” without the later comma. The restoration-passages appendix prints both articles from that printing. ↩︎

  15. SEC order, ¶¶2-3, pp. 2-3; ¶8, p. 3; ¶¶32 and 35, p. 7.Read the passagesOrder of 21 February 2023, Exchange Act Release No. 96951Paragraph 3 (p. 3)Paragraph 8 (p. 3)Paragraph 32 (p. 7) ↩︎

  16. 2 Corinthians 8:9, King James Version.Read the passages2 Corinthians 8 ↩︎