Skip to content
The Mormon DilemmaChrist, Scripture & the Restoration

Find a passage or a question

Search the book

Search the full text of the chapters and source appendices. Enter at least two characters.

Contents
Sources & editions ↗
Text size
Free PDF & EPUB Read offline or on Kindle

Chapter 0111 min read

The eternal Son

In this reading

The One who died for sinners is the Lord who made them. The gospel joins His identity to His saving work: the Word who was with God and was God became flesh,[1] and the Christ who suffered rose from the dead. Repentance and forgiveness are proclaimed in His name.[2][3] We need to know whom we are trusting when we call on Jesus Christ.

The question reaches each of us. Our sin is before God, and we cannot justify ourselves by belonging to the right community, defending a tradition or exposing another person's error. Paul declares that all have sinned and that justification is freely given by God's grace through the redemption in Christ Jesus.[4] The Savior we need is the Savior God has given. We must hear His apostles before deciding whether a later message restores their witness.

With God, and God

Two open books on a table beneath a window.
Illustration

The Gospel of John begins before it tells us about Jesus' public ministry. “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God.” John then says that all things were made through Him and that nothing made came into being without Him.[2] The Word does not enter the account as one of the things whose beginning John explains. He is already there, with God, as the One through whom they came to be.

Both parts of John's confession matter. The Word was with God: He is not simply another name for the Father. The Word was God: His distinction from the Father does not put Him outside the divine identity. John later speaks of the only begotten Son in the Father's bosom, who makes Him known.[5] The Father and the Son are personally distinct. That distinction does not place the Son among the things that were made; John has already set Him apart from them.

The apostles also keep His relation to us clear. Paul confesses one God, the Father, “of whom are all things, and we in him” and one Lord Jesus Christ, “by whom are all things, and we by him.”[6] We belong among those who live through Him. The Son is no rival who takes creatures away from the Father; through Him we have our relation to the Father.

Colossians gathers heaven and earth, the visible and invisible, and thrones, dominions, principalities and powers under the Son's creative work. All were created by Him and for Him, and by Him all things consist.[7] Paul grounds His supremacy in His relation to the whole creation: He is its Maker, its end and the One on whom it depends. He then speaks of Christ as the head of the church and the firstborn from the dead, with preeminence in all things.

Hebrews brings His identity and saving work into the same sentence. God has spoken by His Son, through whom He made the worlds. The Son is “the express image of his person”, “upholding all things by the word of his power”; having purged our sins, He sat down at God's right hand.[8] The One who sustains creation is the One who cleanses sinners. His nearness to us does not diminish His glory, and His glory does not keep Him from coming to save.

This confession gives us the measure for every later explanation of Jesus. We must preserve the whole witness: His distinction from the Father, His deity, and His relation to those He made. A reading that retains one part by changing another must be tested against them together.

The Word became flesh

A clay cup and folded linen beside a stone doorway.
Illustration

John identifies the Word with the One who came among us: “And the Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us”.[1] The Creator entered the life of His creatures. The gospel is God's coming to us in His Son, full of grace and truth.

The incarnation joins the identity of the Savior to the humanity in which He saves. The One who became flesh is the same Word John has already identified as God. John does not introduce a new person when he reaches this sentence, or withdraw what he has said about the Word. The Son comes among us as the One through whom we were made.

Paul describes this humility in Philippians. Christ, “being in the form of God”, “took upon him the form of a servant” and “became obedient unto death, even the death of the cross”.[9] The movement is from His glory into service and suffering. The death He accepts is the death of the cross. God's Son enters the obedience and suffering through which He saves us.

God exalts Him, and every knee is to bow and every tongue confess Him as Lord, to the glory of God the Father.[10] The Father's exaltation of the Son does not make them the same person. Nor does it cancel John's identification of the Word before His coming in flesh. We must hold His eternal identity, His humiliation and His exaltation together.

That matters when we face our need for mercy. We cannot climb out of our guilt by becoming more impressive than our neighbors. We need God to save us. John tells us that grace and truth came by Jesus Christ, and that we receive from His fullness.[11] Our hope begins with what He gives.

His offering for sinners

A cross and a crown of thorns in evening light.
Illustration

Our sin is not a small defect that religious effort can erase. Paul excludes boasting when he proclaims justification through faith, apart from the deeds of the law. God remains just while justifying the one who believes in Jesus.[4] Forgiveness comes through the redemption Christ accomplished. God does not ask us to pretend that evil was good, or that the debt of our sin never mattered.

Hebrews explains the saving offering. We are sanctified through the offering of Christ's body. The repeated sacrifices of the priests could never take away sins, but Christ offered “one sacrifice for sins for ever” and sat down at God's right hand. “For by one offering he hath perfected for ever them that are sanctified.”[12] His sacrifice has accomplished what those repeated sacrifices could not.

The body in which the Word came among us was given in this offering. His cross belongs at the center of the gospel because He gave Himself for sinners.

This grace calls us to repentance. The risen Christ declares that repentance and the remission of sins should be proclaimed in His name.[3] To repent is to turn to Him with the sin we need forgiven. Faith receives His gift; it does not pay Him for it. The distinction Paul makes between grace and a wage is essential to our hope.[13] We need the Savior's offering, and He has made it.

He rose from the dead

An open stone tomb with folded linen.
Illustration

Luke describes Jesus standing among His disciples after His death. They were afraid and supposed they had seen a spirit. Jesus directed them to His hands and feet: “it is I myself”. He invited them to handle Him, explaining that a spirit does not have flesh and bones as they could see He had. He then ate before them.[14] Luke presents the risen Lord Himself, alive in the body.

The resurrection is not simply the survival of His influence or the disciples' resolve to carry on His cause. The One who had died stood among them. Their fear, joy and wondering were answered by His presence. The Christian confession includes this bodily resurrection. To deny it would be to depart from the witness we are asking the reader to examine.

Jesus then opened their understanding of the Scriptures. His suffering, His rising on the third day, and the proclamation of repentance and forgiveness among all nations belong together.[3] He gives the message its center and sends it beyond the circle of those who first heard it. We are among the sinners who need to hear that forgiveness is proclaimed in His name.

The agreement we acknowledge and the teaching we test

Books and a magnifying glass on a desk.
Illustration

The church's testimony The Living Christ, dated 1 January 2000, says of Jesus: “He gave His life to atone for the sins of all mankind.” It also affirms, “He rose from the grave”.[15] These are real affirmations of His saving death and resurrection. The same testimony identifies Him with Jehovah and places His life before His birth. We must not present these truths as things the church denies.

Those affirmations do not settle every question about Christ or about receiving the benefit of His death. The disagreement must be located where the teaching actually differs. Showing that Jesus existed before His birth does not answer a church that teaches His premortal existence. Showing that the Father and the Son are personally distinct does not answer one that affirms that distinction. Christians must state their own confession accurately and test the church's actual account.

The 1916 exposition of the First Presidency and the Twelve places Jesus among the Father's spirit children, uniquely preeminent among them. It understands creation as organization. Doctrine and Covenants 93:29 teaches that intelligence “was not created or made”.[16] The strongest answer therefore says that Christ is divine and creates and sustains the worlds while the intelligence underlying persons has no beginning. It is a substantial answer. The Father's literal parenthood of spirits does not, by itself, exclude the Son's creative work.

The biblical confession gives us the standard for judging that answer. Isaiah declares the Lord without an equal and directs us to the creation that depends on His power. John identifies the Word as God and Maker; Paul places us among those who live through Him. Acts speaks of our receiving life and breath from God, in whom we have our being.[17] We receive our being from the Creator. The biblical promise brings His creatures into life with Him; it does not teach an uncreated core within us that develops into godhood.

The following chapter tests the organization answer against these passages together. The question is whether that later account preserves what Scripture teaches about God and His creatures. The Son who saves us is the eternal Lord through whom we were made; a later teaching that changes that relation changes the Christ we are asked to trust.

Life in the Son

A young olive tree beside a spring.
Illustration

The gospel calls for a response. John says that those who receive Christ, believing on His name, are given the right to become God's children. Their birth is of God, rather than blood or human will.[18] Religious ancestry does not give this life, and the failings of our family or community cannot prevent God from giving it. We must receive the Son.

The apostle John returns to the promise in his first letter. God has given us eternal life, and this life is in His Son. Whoever has the Son has life; whoever does not have the Son of God does not have life. John writes so that believers may know they have it.[19] This is a promise to trust, with a warning we must hear. Our hope rests in the Son Himself.

Good works belong to the life God creates in Christ. Ephesians places them after salvation by grace through faith, as the work for which God has made us anew.[20] They do not become a wage with which we purchase His acceptance. Paul distinguishes the reward owed for work from the righteousness reckoned to the one who believes in the God who justifies the ungodly.[13] We come as sinners who need His grace.

Come to Christ in repentance and faith. Confess the sin you cannot remove and receive the forgiveness proclaimed in His name. The question before us is who this Savior is. We must test the Restoration's answer against the witness God has already given, because the Lord we worship and the gospel we trust are at stake.


Source notes

  1. John 1:14, King James Version.Read the passagesJohn 1 ↩︎ ↩︎

  2. John 1:1-3, King James Version.Read the passagesJohn 1 ↩︎ ↩︎

  3. Luke 24:44-47, King James Version.Read the passagesLuke 24 ↩︎ ↩︎ ↩︎

  4. Romans 3:23-28, King James Version.Read the passagesRomans 3 ↩︎ ↩︎

  5. John 1:1-3, 18, King James Version.Read the passagesJohn 1 ↩︎

  6. 1 Corinthians 8:6, King James Version.Read the passages1 Corinthians 8 ↩︎

  7. Colossians 1:15-18, King James Version. The following chapter examines creation as organization and the proposed exception for uncreated intelligence.Read the passagesColossians 1 ↩︎

  8. Hebrews 1:1-3, King James Version.Read the passagesHebrews 1 ↩︎

  9. Philippians 2:5-8, King James Version.Read the passagesPhilippians 2 ↩︎

  10. Philippians 2:9-11, King James Version.Read the passagesPhilippians 2 ↩︎

  11. John 1:16-17, King James Version.Read the passagesJohn 1 ↩︎

  12. Hebrews 10:10-14, King James Version. In verse 10 this edition supplies the words for all; the appendix marks them in brackets. Verses 12 and 14 state the completed offering in the wording quoted here.Read the passagesHebrews 10 ↩︎

  13. Romans 4:3-8, King James Version.Read the passagesRomans 4 ↩︎ ↩︎

  14. Luke 24:36-43, King James Version.Read the passagesLuke 24 ↩︎

  15. “The Living Christ: The Testimony of the Apostles”, First Presidency and Quorum of the Twelve, 1 January 2000, paragraphs 2-5. An official testimony, distinguished from a standard work. Its affirmations are not presented as agreement on how a sinner is justified. ↩︎

  16. “The Father and the Son,” Improvement Era 19, no. 10 (August 1916), pp. 934-935, 940-942; Doctrine and Covenants 93:29, current wording quoted briefly. The appendix gives the corresponding 1833 manuscript passage. The account concerns uncreated intelligence and spirit parenthood, which are kept distinct.Read the passagesDoctrine and Covenants 93:29, manuscript witness (1833) ↩︎

  17. Isaiah 40:25-26; John 1:1-3; 1 Corinthians 8:6; Acts 17:24-28, King James Version. The next chapter develops the cumulative Creator/creature argument and states the proposed restriction to organized things.Read the passagesIsaiah 40John 1Acts 171 Corinthians 8 ↩︎

  18. John 1:12-13, King James Version.Read the passagesJohn 1 ↩︎

  19. 1 John 5:11-13, King James Version.Read the passages1 John 5 ↩︎

  20. Ephesians 2:8-10, King James Version.Read the passagesEphesians 2 ↩︎