Skip to content
The Mormon DilemmaChrist, Scripture & the Restoration

Find a passage or a question

Search the book

Search the full text of the chapters and source appendices. Enter at least two characters.

Contents
Sources & editions ↗
Text size
Free PDF & EPUB Read offline or on Kindle

Chapter 0710 min read

Faith, testimony and conscience

In this reading

Faith in Jesus Christ does not require us to believe every claim made in His name. The apostles call us to trust Him, and they warn us about false prophets. John writes, “believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God”.[1] Taking that warning seriously is an act of faithfulness to God.

The question may be personal long before it becomes an argument. You may have prayed about the Book of Mormon, received an answer you understood as God's witness, and built your life around it. An author cannot truthfully tell you that you experienced nothing. Nor can the strength of that experience, by itself, settle whether every conclusion drawn from it is true. We must distinguish the experience, its interpretation and the message it is being asked to establish.

Prayer and the promised witness

Folded hands beside an open Bible.
Illustration

Moroni's invitation is more substantial than a request to look for a pleasant feeling. It directs the reader to ask God, the Eternal Father, in Christ's name, “with a sincere heart, with real intent, having faith in Christ”. The promised manifestation is “by the power of the Holy Ghost”.[2] Those conditions and that claimed source belong in any fair account of the invitation.

Doctrine and Covenants 9 also joins thought to prayer. In a revelation addressed to Oliver Cowdery about translating, the instruction is to study the matter in his mind and then ask whether it is right. The text describes a burning in the bosom for what is right and a stupor of thought for what is wrong.[3] It allows a negative answer. A criticism that represents the whole claim as thoughtless emotion, or says the canon provides no possibility of a no, has missed what the texts say.

Christians should gladly affirm that it is right to ask God for wisdom. James tells the person who lacks it to ask the God who gives generously, and to ask in faith.[4] Prayer and careful examination belong together. We need not choose between depending on God and attending to the words before us.

But a command to pray does not establish in advance the truth of the claim being examined. Nor does the sincerity of the one who prays make every interpretation of an answer correct. The question remains: has God borne witness to this message? We must not answer it simply by repeating our conviction that He has.

Christians also depend on the Spirit

An oil lamp and an open book beside a curtain.
Illustration

There is a serious objection here. Paul says, “The Spirit itself beareth witness with our spirit, that we are the children of God”.[5] If Christians depend on an inward witness, why should they dismiss a Latter-day Saint's witness merely because it is inward?

They should not. The presence of inward conviction is not the difference that establishes one teaching as true and another as false. The Christian must submit his own convictions to God's judgment. A confidence held by this book's author has no exemption from the test applied to the reader's confidence.

Paul's witness has a stated content: adoption as God's children, through the Spirit by whom we cry to the Father. It belongs within his proclamation of life in Christ. John likewise joins the witness within the believer to God's testimony concerning His Son and to the eternal life God gives in Him.[5][6] These passages are not a grant of infallibility to every conviction a believer subsequently forms.

A Latter-day Saint may rightly reply that Moroni's promise also has content: the truth of the record, and the truth of all things. John likewise writes that believers have an anointing and know all things. The difference cannot be established by pretending that only the Christian witness concerns truth. John's context supplies the test. He tells believers, “Let that therefore abide in you, which ye have heard from the beginning”, and says he is writing about those who seduce them. The anointing keeps them in that first message; it does not authorize a later message to reverse it.[7] A claimed witness to the Book of Mormon must therefore be examined beside the message it asks us to receive. Calling that witness divine cannot settle the disagreement before the messages are compared.

God is able to make truth known. Our need to test a claimed revelation does not deny His power to reveal. It distinguishes His truthful witness from our claim to have understood or received it. Jesus says that the Spirit of truth will testify of Him.[8] The Spirit's work does not give us permission to replace the Christ whom the apostles proclaim with a conflicting account and then appeal to the strength of our assurance.

This applies equally to Christians. A person can quote the Bible while using it badly. A church can defend its traditions instead of hearing Christ. We must examine what is actually being taught and how the passages are being read. Calling an interpretation Christian does not relieve its author of that duty.

Try the message

Two open books beneath a magnifying glass.
Illustration

First John does not tell us to accept every spirit that claims divine authority. It directs us to the confession of Jesus Christ come in the flesh, and then to hearing the apostolic witness: “he that knoweth God heareth us”.[1] John identifies that witness at the beginning of the letter: those who heard, saw and handled the Word of life declare what they saw and heard.[9] A later body claiming apostolic office must be tested by that original testimony. A later office, however it is received, does not make its holders the witnesses John names. The test concerns Christ as those first witnesses make Him known.

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints affirms that Jesus came in flesh. We must acknowledge that rather than treating the bare words of John's incarnation test as an automatic disproof of the church. The examination must consider the whole testimony about Him: who He is, His relation to the Father, His creating work, His saving death and the life He gives. Chapters 1 and 2 have set out that witness and tested the proposed exception for an uncreated human core.

Paul makes the same demand when he warns against another gospel. His warning reaches even his own party and an angel from heaven.[10] An impressive messenger does not make a changed gospel true. Equally, the mere claim that an angel appeared does not make the message false. Its content must be examined before Paul's judgment is applied.

The earlier chapters have argued that the later account changes the relation between God and His creatures. A personal assurance cannot make that change a restoration of the apostolic witness. This is why the doctrinal examination matters to the testimony question. The Christian reply is an argument from the message, rather than a claim to possess stronger feelings than the reader.

Moroni's own invitation calls for faith in Christ. That brings us back to the question of whom we trust. We cannot settle Christ's identity by first accepting the later account of Him and then using our confidence in that account to decide what the apostles must have meant. The earlier witness must be allowed to speak.

Receive the word and examine it

An open book with a lifted page.
Illustration

Acts describes people in Berea who received Paul's message readily and searched the Scriptures daily to see whether these things were so. Many believed.[11] Readiness to hear and willingness to examine were joined. Their examination was not portrayed as hostility to God.

The point is especially important because the messenger was Paul. A claim to apostolic authority did not turn examination of the Scriptures into disobedience. The church's appeal to the Bible, and the Book of Mormon's appeal to the earlier record, likewise give the reader reason to compare the actual messages. The translation qualification must be considered, as Chapter 2 explains; it cannot be allowed to remove every possible test of a later claim.

Paul tells Timothy that the holy Scriptures can make him wise for salvation through faith in Christ Jesus. They instruct, reprove and correct, equipping God's servant for good works.[12] Correction is part of their good work. We do not honor Scripture by protecting our reading from correction.

This passage does not, by itself, prove that no further revelation could ever be given. It establishes Scripture's place in forming and correcting faith. A later message that claims to restore the apostolic gospel must face the earlier testimony it professes to confirm. The test is not evaded by insisting that only someone who already accepts the later authority can understand it.

Bring the difficult passages into the examination. A Christian reply must answer the actual argument, including its strongest form. Where we have misunderstood a source, we must correct ourselves. Where a question remains unanswered, repeating the conclusion more loudly is no answer. Seeking the truth requires patience as well as conviction.

Conscience before God

A chair and a book facing an open landscape.
Illustration

Article of Faith 11 claims the privilege of worship according to conscience and says to “allow all men the same privilege”, letting them worship how, where or what they may.[13] That profession should leave room for the reader to examine a claim honestly. Freedom to examine is not proof that every conclusion is equally true. It is freedom to seek the truth without pretending to believe what one does not believe.

Paul says that each of us will give account of himself to God. When the apostles were commanded to stop their witness to Jesus, they answered, “We ought to obey God rather than men.”[14] Human approval cannot take God's place. Neither a church's demand nor an author's demand can relieve us of responsibility before Him.

A decision can carry pain where family, friendship and years of service are involved. Do not turn that pain into contempt for those you love. Tell the truth about what they teach and do. Do not invent motives or repeat an allegation because it would help your argument. Christian wrongdoing faces the same standard. Faithfulness to Christ gives no permission for cruelty.

Yet affection cannot make a false teaching true. If the message changes the God we worship or the gospel we receive, we must reject the error even when doing so costs us the approval of people we love. We need mercy before God, and we owe our neighbor a truthful witness to the Savior.

Jesus joins knowing the truth and being made free to continuing in His word.[15] Keep praying as you examine. Ask for wisdom, read the passages, hear the strongest answer and follow what is true. Bring your fear and sin to Christ. The goal is to know Him and receive His life, with a conscience that answers to God.


Source notes

  1. 1 John 4:1-6, King James Version. The confession of the incarnation is read with the letter's appeal to the apostolic witness; it is not treated as a denial that the church confesses Christ's coming in flesh.Read the passages1 John 4 ↩︎ ↩︎

  2. Moroni 10:4-5, current wording quoted briefly. The complete corresponding 1830 passage, p. 586, appears in the appendix with its additional and before he will manifest identified.Read the passagesMoroni 10:4-5, first edition (1830) ↩︎

  3. Doctrine and Covenants 9:7-9, current text. Its heading places the instruction in Oliver Cowdery's attempt to translate. The complete corresponding units are printed from the disclosed 1923 reading transcription, with the uncertain page numeral identified.Read the passagesDoctrine and Covenants 9:7Doctrine and Covenants 9:8Doctrine and Covenants 9:9 ↩︎

  4. James 1:5-8, King James Version.Read the passagesJames 1 ↩︎

  5. Romans 8:15-17, King James Version.Read the passagesRomans 8 ↩︎ ↩︎

  6. 1 John 5:9-13, King James Version. God's witness to the Son and eternal life supplies the content of the passage.Read the passages1 John 5 ↩︎

  7. 1 John 2:20-27, King James Version. The promise to teach all things is read with the command to remain in what was heard from the beginning and the warning about seduction.Read the passages1 John 2 ↩︎

  8. John 15:26, King James Version.Read the passagesJohn 15 ↩︎

  9. 1 John 1:1-3, King James Version.Read the passages1 John 1 ↩︎

  10. Galatians 1:6-9, King James Version.Read the passagesGalatians 1 ↩︎

  11. Acts 17:10-12, King James Version.Read the passagesActs 17 ↩︎

  12. 2 Timothy 3:14-17, King James Version. The passage's use of Scripture for salvation, correction and good works is distinguished from a separate argument about when the canon closed.Read the passages2 Timothy 3 ↩︎

  13. Article of Faith 11; “Church History,” Times and Seasons 3, no. 9 (1 March 1842), p. 710. The full historical statement and its small wording differences from the current edition are given in the appendix.Read the passagesArticle of Faith 11, first printing (1842) ↩︎

  14. Romans 14:12; Acts 5:29, King James Version.Read the passagesActs 5Romans 14 ↩︎

  15. John 8:31-32, King James Version.Read the passagesJohn 8 ↩︎