Skip to content
The Mormon DilemmaChrist, Scripture & the Restoration

Find a passage or a question

Search the book

Search the full text of the chapters and source appendices. Enter at least two characters.

Contents
Sources & editions ↗
Text size
Free PDF & EPUB Read offline or on Kindle

Sources & reading aids5 min read

Sources, editions and corrections

In this reading

The book begins with the church's four standard works. Its notes distinguish those scriptures from official declarations, publications, conference sermons and scholarship. A manual's inclusion of a sermon does not canonize it. An apologist's explanation is attributed to that author or organization. The Christian conclusions are the book's arguments from the passages, rather than words put into a source's mouth.

Bible

Bible quotations follow the retained eBible/CrossWire King James Version digital text, described by its distributor as the standardized 1769 text. The prose uses its ordinary-type XML wording; the Bible appendix preserves the corresponding TXT witness's supplied-word brackets and paragraph marks. Both witnesses have been compared for the cited units. The archive is identified by SHA-256 00d2b622b528b42604c23fddf21fe707a1c79d0b5b2ea480c4b96359b0c9eac3.

The source-text profile of this edition is for United States distribution. The King James Version's printing and import rights in the United Kingdom have not been cleared.

Restoration texts

The complete historical selections identify their own editions: the Book of Mormon's 1830, 1837 and 1840 printings; the 1842 Times and Seasons; the 1833 revelation manuscript, the 1843 Kingsbury copy and the Richards report; and the 1923 printing of the Doctrine and Covenants, copyright 1921. Other historical witnesses include the 1916 Improvement Era exposition, the 1844 Times and Seasons printing of the King Follett sermon, the Joseph Smith Papers transcript of the printer's manuscript, and the 1817 Methodist and 1818 Philadelphia Baptist confessions. The Lectures on Faith are read in Project Gutenberg's named transcription of the 1835 text. The Book of Mormon's witness statements are read in Gutenberg eBook #17, whose base printing is not identified. That digital witness is never passed off as an independently collated 1830 printing.

Current-edition comparisons use the official texts retained on 15 November 2026. Current wording is identified as current, and material differences from the older witness are stated. A retained transcript is distinguished from a page image. The 1923 D&C selections use a disclosed OCR reading transcription: line wrapping, study callouts and interleaved apparatus are removed with a record of the changes; uncertain page numerals are identified. No claim of facsimile collation follows from an OCR comparison. Editorially supplied letters or page numbers in manuscript transcripts remain visible.

Underlying public-domain texts supply the extended historical selections where a retained witness is available. Brief current passages needed for context are identified separately. Modern official publications and scholarship are quoted briefly with attribution, rather than reproduced as complete articles. Scan images are not reproduced. Edition-specific reproduction questions remain separate from whether a quotation is accurate.

Other witnesses

The early Christian passages follow The Ante-Nicene Fathers, volume 1, in its Buffalo 1887 printing; the notes identify work, chapter and printed page. Ignatius is quoted from the shorter recension. Broad dates are used where no modern critical dating reference has been pinned.

The Septuagint comparison uses the retained English Brenton witness described by its distributor as published in 1851. Its Psalm 39 corresponds to Psalm 40 in the Hebrew numbering. Westcott and Hort are quoted from their 1882 Introduction and Appendix. Latter-day Saint scholars' views are heard in their own words, including the arguments that do not favor this book's conclusion.

The public-records appendix follows the Securities and Exchange Commission's PDF of its order of 21 February 2023, Exchange Act Release No. 96951, a work of the United States government (SHA-256 fae9e265b5db58e1349ed108070b6a7fed22c9c35154500ed3aaac438234cc0b). The 2026 Form 13F-HR figures are Ensign Peak's own filing, retained from the Commission's EDGAR system. The Commission staff's answers about Form 13F and the Internal Revenue Service's guidance for churches are cited as guidance, not as rulings about any particular entity. Each was retained on 16 November 2026.

The witness interviews follow their original printings: Tiffany’s Monthly for August 1859, in the scan published by IAPSOP, and The Saints’ Herald for 1 October 1879, in the Internet Archive's scan of its volume, whose page images carry a LatterDayTruth.org watermark. The 1830 preface is read from the Internet Archive's scan of a first-edition copy. The scans were used for reading; the book prints the public-domain text, not the images. Two readers read each unit from the page images independently, and their texts were compared word for word. The printed spellings, such as “metalic” and “neccessary”, are kept.

Corrections

A criticism of a false quotation or an unfair account of the church's teaching should identify the sentence, the named edition and the passage that corrects it. The same standard applies when a Christian source has been overstated. A correction should say what changed and when; it should not silently preserve an argument after the evidence supporting it has failed.

Some questions remain open without being used as accusations: the precise motives for textual changes, a global account of ancient American archaeology, unheld manuscript evidence, the church's own account of the matters in the 2023 SEC order, and the disputed prediction discussed in Chapter 5. The book's conclusions rest on the arguments it actually makes. A missing answer is not replaced by an allegation.

AI assistance

AI systems assisted in research, source comparison, drafting and review. Quotations were checked against named retained witnesses by independent readers before integration. That process verifies the words of those witnesses; it does not make an interpretation infallible or turn a historical assertion into an established event. The argument remains open to correction from Scripture and accurately represented sources.

This edition

This is the first edition, dated 17 November 2026. It is offered free as a website, a PDF and an EPUB, all made from the same text. The illustrations are AI-generated thematic images made for this edition. They are not photographs of historical places, people or documents, and they are not evidence for any claim in the book. The PDF is set in Source Serif 4, Libre Caslon Display and DM Sans, which are distributed under the SIL Open Font License.

Illustration and edition credits ↑