In this reading
Books that are copied and printed many times are changed, and a change proves nothing by itself. The Bible comes to us through centuries of hand copying. The Book of Mormon has been revised since its first printing, beginning with its own translator. Christians must judge both books by one standard: what changed, what evidence shows it, and whether the change alters the witness to God and salvation. The Restoration rests on a claim of change: that plain and precious things were taken from the Bible and have now been restored. Yet Christians who knew the apostles, or learned from those who did, still speak, and they confess the gospel the Bible preserves. The change that matters lies elsewhere, in the Restoration's own account of God. Its first scripture calls Jesus “the Eternal God”, and teaches that God is “unchangeable from all eternity to all eternity”.[1][2] Its later scripture describes a Father with “a body of flesh and bones”, and promises exalted husbands and wives, “Then shall they be gods”.[3][4]
The strongest answer is that God speaks to His servants “in their weakness, after the manner of their language”, and reveals truth line upon line.[5] Biblical prophets also wrote their words a second time and added to them. We grant that a revised text and a fuller revelation are both possible. But a later revelation must agree with what God has already said about Himself. Scripture says that God is spirit, that the Son became flesh, and that God is God from everlasting. At those points the later account does not add to the earlier witness. It says something different. The Bible's words did not change between 1830 and 1921. The teaching did. The Savior we need is the One the apostles proclaimed: “Jesus Christ the same yesterday, and to day, and for ever.”[6]
One standard for both books

The New Testament comes to us through many handwritten copies, and the copies differ in many small readings. Christians do not claim that every copyist worked without error. We claim that the text preserved through those copies still carries the apostles' witness, so that John's purpose is still served: “these are written, that ye might believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God; and that believing ye might have life through his name.”[7] We must apply the same fairness to the Book of Mormon. Most changes to its text since 1830 concern spelling, grammar and punctuation. Counting them is not an argument.
The Book of Mormon does not claim to be free of human error. The title page of its first edition says, “And now if there be fault, it be the mistake of men; wherefore condemn not the things of God”. The current title page reads, “if there are faults they are the mistakes of men”.[8] The second edition, published at Kirtland in 1837, told its readers that the whole had been “carefully re-examined and compared with the original manuscripts, by elder Joseph Smith, Jr. the translator of the book of Mormon”.[9] The Doctrine and Covenants says that the Lord's commandments “were given unto my servants in their weakness, after the manner of their language, that they might come to understanding”.[5] Scripture itself records a prophet's words written a second time. After King Jehoiakim burned Jeremiah's scroll, Baruch wrote the words again, “and there were added besides unto them many like words.”[10] A revised text is not disproved by its revision.
Was the Bible changed?

The Restoration makes its own claim of change, and it concerns the Bible. In Nephi's vision the apostles' record goes “in purity unto the Gentiles”. Then a great and abominable church takes away from the gospel of the Lamb “many parts which are plain and most precious”, together with “many covenants of the Lord”.[11] Latter-day Saint scholars do not generally picture medieval monks rewriting the Bible. Stephen E. Robinson of Brigham Young University called that picture “bigoted and unfair”. He argued that the church Nephi describes “had its origins in the second half of the first century and had essentially done its work by the middle of the second century”, a period he called “the blind spot of ecclesiastical history”.[12] If the loss came before the copies we have, the copies would not show it. That answer is coherent, and it cannot be answered from manuscripts alone.
But the period is not silent. Christians who wrote within it still speak. Clement of Rome, whom Irenaeus describes as one who “had seen the blessed apostles, and had been conversant with them”, told the church at Corinth, “Take up the epistle of the blessed Apostle Paul.”[13] Polycarp, who according to Irenaeus “was not only instructed by apostles, and conversed with many who had seen Christ”, urged the Philippians to “return to the word which has been handed down to us from the beginning”.[14] Ignatius called Christ “God existing in flesh”, and wrote of the risen Lord, “I know that after His resurrection also He was still possessed of flesh”.[15] Justin Martyr reports that at the Sunday gathering “the memoirs of the apostles or the writings of the prophets are read, as long as time permits”.[16]
These writers do not prove that no word was ever lost. They show what the church inside Robinson's window believed and read. Robinson holds that, to appeal to a wider Gentile audience, Christianity had to “discard the doctrines of an anthropomorphic God and the resurrection of the dead” or reinterpret them. The writers of the period insist on the resurrection. Polycarp calls the one who denies the resurrection and the judgment “the first-born of Satan”, and Ignatius confesses the risen Lord in the flesh. When Marcion did cut the Gospel of Luke, the church noticed. Irenaeus wrote that Marcion “mutilates the Gospel which is according to Luke, removing all that is written respecting the generation of the Lord”.[17] Irenaeus calls Marcion the only one who dared to do this openly, so his words do not exclude every hidden change. They do show that the apostles' writings were held by many churches, and that an attempt to cut them was seen and named.
A loss can explain a silence. It cannot explain what is still there. The passages on which this book's argument rests, among them John 1, Colossians 1, Isaiah 44 and Romans 3 and 4, stand in the Bible the church itself uses. The disagreements this book examines concern what the Bible says, not what it lacks. When the Restoration's teaching differs from those words, a lost passage cannot account for the difference.
Four readings in Nephi's vision

The revision of 1837 that bears most directly on Christ falls in Nephi's vision. In the first edition the angel says of the virgin that she “is the mother of God, after the manner of the flesh”. He then says, “behold the Lamb of God, yea, even the Eternal Father!” Nephi sees the Lamb taken by the people: “yea, the Everlasting God, was judged of the world”. The last records are to make known “that the Lamb of God is the Eternal Father and the Saviour of the world”.[18] In the 1837 edition each passage reads “the Son of”: “the mother of the Son of God”; “yea, even the Son of the Eternal Father!”; “yea, the Son of the everlasting God was judged of the world”; and “the Son of the eternal Father”.[19] The current text follows 1837. The printer's manuscript, from which the first edition was set, has the first-edition readings. The sources establish what changed, when it changed and who re-examined the text. They do not say why, and we will not supply a reason.
The edits do not all point the same way. Two of the first-edition readings confess what Christians confess. Elisabeth greets Mary as “the mother of my Lord”, and the One judged by the world was God the Son in the flesh.[20] The first chapter of this book confessed the same: the One who became flesh is the Word who was God. At those two places, the words “the Son of” remove a direct confession that the incarnate Son is God. The other two first-edition readings call the Lamb “the Eternal Father”. John distinguishes the Word from the Father with whom He was, and at those places the 1837 wording stands nearer to John.
The church has explained why its scripture calls Christ “Father”. In 1916 the First Presidency and the Twelve wrote that “Jesus Christ, being the Creator, is consistently called the Father of heaven and earth”. On that reading, “Eternal Father” in the vision is a title of the Creator, and “the Son of” makes plain which person is meant. The Book of Mormon still calls Christ “the very Eternal Father of heaven and of earth”.[21] The revision did not remove that language from the book, and we do not treat it as concealment.
A question remains about the kind of text the Book of Mormon is. Its title page says it came forth “by the gift and power of God”.[8] To call the Lamb “the Eternal Father” and to call Him “the Son of the eternal Father” are different statements. If the English words were given to Joseph Smith, the 1837 edition changed words that were given. If the English was his own expression of the sense, the wording at these points is his. The next chapter takes up that question.
What the first edition does show is how high it places Christ. Its title page calls Jesus “the Eternal God”, and the current title page still does. Abinadi teaches that “God himself shall come down among the children of men, and shall redeem his people”. Amulek calls the Son of God “the beginning and the end, the first and the last”, titles Scripture gives to the Lord who has no equal.[1] However its titles for Christ are explained, the Book of Mormon places Jesus on the Creator's side.
The account of God

The Book of Mormon speaks directly about how many Gods there are. Zeezrom asks Amulek, “Is there more than one God? And he answereth No.” Nephi ends his teaching on the way of salvation with “the only and true doctrine of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost, which is one God, without end.”[22] Latter-day Saints read these verses as describing the unity of the Godhead: distinct beings who are one in purpose. Christians confess the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit as one God. The phrase alone cannot decide between the two accounts, and a count of the words “one God” against “Gods” refutes nothing. The question is what kind of being God is, and whether He has always been God.
The Book of Mormon speaks to that question too. Mormon writes that “God is not a partial God, neither a changeable being; but he is unchangeable from all eternity to all eternity.” Moroni writes that whoever has imagined “a god who doth vary” has imagined “a god who is not a God of miracles”, and declares of God, “he changeth not; if so he would cease to be God”.[2] The Doctrine and Covenants confesses God “from everlasting to everlasting the same unchangeable God, the framer of heaven and earth”.[23] These agree with the Psalm: “from everlasting to everlasting, thou art God.”[24]
God's unchangeability does not forbid Him to make more of Himself known. Nor do these sentences settle the dispute alone. The revelation on marriage says of the exalted, “therefore shall they be from everlasting to everlasting, because they continue”, and Latter-day Saints read the earlier phrases in that light.[25] We must look at what the later texts say God is.
In 1835 the church published its first Doctrine and Covenants. Its first part, on the church's doctrine, was a series of seven lectures on faith. The fifth names the Father and the Son as the supreme power over all things: “the Father being a personage of spirit, glory, and power”, and the Son, “who was in the bosom of the Father, a personage of tabernacle”. A general assembly of the church met on 17 August 1835 to decide whether the book should be approved, “that it may, if approved, become a law unto the church, and a rule of faith and practice unto the same”, and accepted it.[26] The editors of the Joseph Smith Papers report, “Modern scholars, however, largely agree that Rigdon authored most or all of the lectures.” In 1921 the church removed the lectures, explaining that they “were never presented to nor accepted by the Church as being otherwise than theological lectures or lessons”.[27] The lectures were not presented as revelations, and the assembly's acceptance of the book cannot be stretched into a vote on each of their sentences. They show what the church printed as the doctrinal part of its book in 1835.
In 1843 Joseph Smith taught at Ramus, Illinois: “The Father has a body of flesh and bones as tangible as man’s; the Son also”. That instruction is now section 130 of the Doctrine and Covenants.[3] The Book of Abraham, published in 1842 and now in the Pearl of Great Price, says of the creation, “they, that is the Gods, organized and formed the heavens and the earth”. A letter Joseph Smith dictated in Liberty Jail in 1839, now section 121, speaks of “the Council of the Eternal God of all other gods”. The revelation on marriage says of those who keep its covenant, “Then shall they be gods”.[4] The previous chapter tested that promise.
In April 1844 Joseph Smith preached the sermon later called the King Follett discourse. The church's manual of his teachings prints this line from it: “God Himself was once as we are now, and is an exalted man”. The church's essay “Becoming Like God” says that “the surviving sermon text is not canonized and should not be treated as a doctrinal standard in and of itself”. Of Lorenzo Snow's couplet, “As man now is, God once was”, the essay says, “Little has been revealed about the first half of this couplet, and consequently little is taught.”[28] The sermon is neither canon nor an isolated opinion. The church prints it for study and declines to make it a standard.
Line upon line

The strongest Latter-day Saint answer is that revelation unfolds. Isaiah speaks of “precept upon precept; line upon line”, and Latter-day Saints apply those words to the way God teaches His people.[29] Hebrews says that God spoke “at sundry times and in divers manners” before He spoke by His Son.[30] On this view, God gave Joseph Smith more light as he could receive it. The lectures were Sidney Rigdon's theology rather than revelation. “One God” means the unity of the Godhead, and the Father's body was always true but not yet revealed.
Much of this we grant. Revelation in Scripture unfolds. Hebrews 1 does not deny that the apostles received revelation after Jesus ascended. Jude's charge to “earnestly contend for the faith which was once delivered unto the saints” calls the church to keep the faith it received; by itself, it does not settle whether God may speak again.[31] The lectures' authorship and standing are disputed, and their removal does not by itself tell us what standing they once had.
But unfolding has a limit. God may tell His people more about Himself. He does not tell them that what He has already said of Himself is untrue. The later account must be tested at two points, one in the canon and one in a sermon the church still prints.
The first is the Father's body. Jesus tells the Samaritan woman that the Father will be worshiped neither on her mountain nor at Jerusalem, and gives the reason: “God is a Spirit”.[32] Paul calls the Son “the image of the invisible God”, and speaks of God as the One “whom no man hath seen, nor can see”. John says, “No man hath seen God at any time”, and then tells how the only begotten Son has declared Him.[33] In Scripture, flesh belongs to the Son who took it: “the Word was made flesh”. Latter-day Saints answer that a spirit may dwell in a glorified body, as the risen Son's does; that God made humanity in His image; and that the Lord spoke with Moses face to face. Christians also confess that the risen Son, who is God, has a body. But His body is the flesh He took when He came among us, and the passages heard here say nothing of the Father taking flesh. The image Paul names is the Son, and the God He images is invisible. The chapter of Exodus that says “the LORD spake unto Moses face to face, as a man speaketh unto his friend” also records the Lord's words, “Thou canst not see my face: for there shall no man see me, and live.”[34] The church's Bible footnote to John 4:24 offers Joseph Smith's revision of the verse: “For unto such hath God promised his Spirit.” A revision cannot serve as the evidence for itself. Taken together, these passages describe the Father as spirit and invisible, and they keep flesh for the Son's coming among us. On the Father, the 1835 lecture stood where these passages stand, calling Him “a personage of spirit”. The later teaching gave Him a body of flesh and bones. That body is not drawn from these passages; it is supplied by the teaching under examination, and it does not fit the witness they give together.
The second concerns God's eternity. The Psalm, Mormon and Moroni say that God is God from everlasting and does not change. Joseph Smith's own account of 1832, which the church's manual prints, describes God as the Being “who was and is and will be from all eternity to eternity”. The sermon of 1844, as printed that year, says otherwise: “I am going to tell you how God came to be God. We have imagined that God was God from all eternity.” It adds that “God himself; the Father of us all dwelt on an earth the same as Jesus Christ himself did”.[35] The same printed sermon calls God self-existing; the dispute is over Godhood, not merely existence. Latter-day Saints answer that the eternal Son became mortal without ceasing to be divine, and that the sermon may say no more than that of the Father. But the sermon does not say that God was God while He dwelt on an earth. It sets out to tell how God came to be God, against the idea that He was God from all eternity. The church's essay is right that the sermon is not a doctrinal standard. Yet the church does not reject the line its manual prints; its essay says that little has been revealed about it. A restoration of the apostles' faith should be able to say what the apostles said: that God is “the King eternal, immortal, invisible, the only wise God”.[36] The earlier witness, Joseph Smith's own account of 1832 among it, answered a question that the later teaching leaves open.
Neither problem comes from a lost Bible. The words of Scripture about God as spirit and about His eternity stand in the edition the church uses, as they stood when the lectures were printed and when they were removed. The teaching changed.
The Christ who does not change

This matters because of who Christ is. The Word who was with God and was God did not grow into deity. He came down from that glory, took the form of a servant and became obedient to death for us.[37] The sermon describes a God who came to be God. The apostles proclaim the eternal God who came down to save those who could not rise.
That is good news for people who change. Our resolutions fail, our understanding grows and falters, and we cannot make ourselves faithful. The Lord says, “I am the LORD, I change not; therefore ye sons of Jacob are not consumed.”[38] His unchanging faithfulness is why the guilty are spared. The apostles' Savior is “the same yesterday, and to day, and for ever.”[6] Turn from every account of God that changes what He has said of Himself. Bring your changing heart to the Christ who does not change, and trust His one offering for sins.[39]
Source notes
Title page, Book of Mormon (1830), p. [i], and current title page; Mosiah 15:1, Book of Mormon (1830), p. 186; Alma 11:39, Book of Mormon (1830), p. 253; Isaiah 44:6; Revelation 22:13, King James Version. The quoted clause of Mosiah 15:1 and the cited part of Alma 11:39 agrees with the first edition, apart from capitalization and punctuation.Read the passagesIsaiah 44Revelation 22Title page, first edition (1830)Mosiah 15:1-4, first edition (1830)Alma 11:28-29 and 38-39, first edition (1830) ↩︎ ↩︎
Moroni 8:18; Mormon 9:10, 19, current text, quoted briefly. Mormon 9:19 belongs to an argument that God still works miracles; the quotation is used for its statement about God.Read the passagesMormon 9:10 (current text only)Mormon 9:19 (current text only)Moroni 8:18 (current text only) ↩︎ ↩︎
Doctrine and Covenants 130:22, current text, quoted briefly; section heading dated 2 April 1843. The 1843 report by Willard Richards contains the statement about the Father's body in its own words.Read the passagesDoctrine and Covenants 130:22, 1843 report ↩︎ ↩︎
Abraham 4:1; Doctrine and Covenants 121:32; 132:20, current text, quoted briefly. Section 121's heading dates the letters to March 1839. ↩︎ ↩︎
Doctrine and Covenants 1:24, current text, quoted briefly.Read the passagesDoctrine and Covenants 1:24 (1923 printing) ↩︎ ↩︎
Hebrews 13:8, King James Version.Read the passagesHebrews 13 ↩︎ ↩︎
Title page, Book of Mormon (Palmyra, 1830), p. [i]; current title page of the Book of Mormon, quoted briefly. The appendix prints the first edition's complete sentence.Read the passagesTitle page, first edition (1830) ↩︎ ↩︎
Preface, Book of Mormon (Kirtland, 1837), p. v, signed by the publishers Parley P. Pratt and John Goodson, p. vi.Read the passagesPreface, second edition (1837) ↩︎
Jeremiah 36:32, King James Version.Read the passagesJeremiah 36 ↩︎
1 Nephi 13:25-26, current text, quoted briefly. The passage's sequence runs from verse 24 to verse 29.Read the passages1 Nephi 13:24-29, first edition (1830) ↩︎
Stephen E. Robinson, “Early Christianity and 1 Nephi 13-14,” in The Book of Mormon: First Nephi, The Doctrinal Foundation (Provo, UT: Religious Studies Center, Brigham Young University, 1988), 177-191. Latter-day Saint scholarship, not an official declaration; quoted briefly. ↩︎
1 Clement 47; Irenaeus, Against Heresies 3.3.3. The Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1 (Buffalo: Christian Literature, 1887 printing), pp. 18 and 416. The writers in this section are dated broadly, from the end of the first century to the middle of the second.Read the passages1 Clement 47 ↩︎
Polycarp, To the Philippians 7; Irenaeus, Against Heresies 3.3.4. Ante-Nicene Fathers 1:34 and 1:416.Read the passagesPolycarp, Philippians 7 ↩︎
Ignatius, To the Ephesians 7 and To the Smyrnaeans 3, shorter recension. Ante-Nicene Fathers 1:52 and 1:87. The longer recension, a later expanded text, is not quoted.Read the passagesIgnatius, Ephesians 7, shorter recension ↩︎
Justin Martyr, First Apology 67. Ante-Nicene Fathers 1:186. ↩︎
Robinson, “Early Christianity and 1 Nephi 13-14”; Polycarp, To the Philippians 7, Ante-Nicene Fathers 1:34; Irenaeus, Against Heresies 1.27.2, 4, Ante-Nicene Fathers 1:352.Read the passages1 Nephi 13:40-41, second edition (1837)1 Nephi 13:24-29, first edition (1830)1 Nephi 13:40, first edition (1830)Polycarp, Philippians 7Irenaeus, Against Heresies 1.27.2 ↩︎
1 Nephi 11:18, 21, 32; 13:40. Book of Mormon (1830), pp. 25, 26 and 32. The printer's manuscript has the same readings, pp. 16, 17 and 22, in the Joseph Smith Papers transcript. The appendix prints the complete verses.Read the passages1 Nephi 11:18, 21, 32, first edition (1830)1 Nephi 13:40, first edition (1830) ↩︎
Book of Mormon (1837), pp. 27, 28, 29 and 35. The current text follows these readings, with capitalization and punctuation differences. ↩︎
Luke 1:43, King James Version; compare John 1:1-3, 14 and Philippians 2:6-8.Read the passagesLuke 1John 1Philippians 2 ↩︎
“The Father and the Son,” Improvement Era 19, no. 10 (August 1916), p. 935, section on “Father” as Creator, citing Alma 11:38-39 and Mosiah 15:4; compare the church's April 2002 reprint. Alma 11:39 and Mosiah 15:4, current text, quoted briefly. ↩︎
Alma 11:28-29, Book of Mormon (1830), p. 253 (the current text reads “answered”); 2 Nephi 31:21, Book of Mormon (1830), p. 120, with the same words in the current text. The appendix prints both passages.Read the passages2 Nephi 31:19-21, first edition (1830)Alma 11:28-29 and 38-39, first edition (1830) ↩︎
Doctrine and Covenants 20:17, current text, quoted briefly.Read the passagesDoctrine and Covenants 20:17 (1923 printing) ↩︎
Psalm 90:2, King James Version.Read the passagesPsalms 90 ↩︎
Doctrine and Covenants 132:20, current text, quoted briefly. The verse's conditions are discussed in the previous chapter.Read the passagesDoctrine and Covenants 132:20, Kingsbury copy (1843) ↩︎
“Lecture Fifth,” paragraph 2, Doctrine and Covenants of the Church of the Latter Day Saints (Kirtland, 1835), lecture beginning p. 52, read in Project Gutenberg eBook #56684, a transcription of the 1835 text by the Mormon Texts Project. The assembly's words are from the minutes of 17 August 1835, as quoted in the Joseph Smith Papers' introduction to the 1835 edition; the minutes were also printed in that edition, pp. 255-257.Read the passagesLectures on Faith, Lecture 5, paragraph 2 (1835) ↩︎
Joseph Smith Papers, introduction to Doctrine and Covenants, 1835, quoted briefly; “Explanatory Introduction,” The Doctrine and Covenants (Salt Lake City, copyright 1921), read in a 1923 printing.Read the passagesExplanatory Introduction, Doctrine and Covenants (copyright 1921) ↩︎
Teachings of Presidents of the Church: Joseph Smith (2011), chapter 2; “Becoming Like God,” Gospel Topics essay, paragraphs on the King Follett discourse and on Lorenzo Snow's couplet. A manual and an official essay, distinguished from canon; quoted briefly. ↩︎
Isaiah 28:10, King James Version.Read the passagesIsaiah 28 ↩︎
Hebrews 1:1-2, King James Version.Read the passagesHebrews 1 ↩︎
Jude 3, King James Version. ↩︎
John 4:21-24, King James Version. In John 4 the statement grounds worship of the Father that is bound to neither mountain nor city.Read the passagesJohn 4 ↩︎
Colossians 1:15; 1 Timothy 6:16; John 1:14, 18, King James Version.Read the passagesJohn 1Colossians 11 Timothy 6 ↩︎
Genesis 1:26-27; Exodus 33:11, 20, King James Version. The church's footnote to John 4:24 in its edition of the King James Version cites the Joseph Smith Translation, John 4:26; quoted briefly.Read the passagesGenesis 1Exodus 33John 4 ↩︎
Joseph Smith, History, 1832, pp. 2-3, as quoted in Teachings of Presidents of the Church: Joseph Smith (2011), chapter 2, with the manual's modernized punctuation; “Conference Minutes,” Times and Seasons 5, no. 15 (15 August 1844), pp. 614-615, retained primary transcript via the Joseph Smith Papers. The sermon is not canonized; the church's essay “Becoming Like God” says it “should not be treated as a doctrinal standard in and of itself”. ↩︎
1 Timothy 1:17, King James Version.Read the passages1 Timothy 1 ↩︎
John 1:1-3, 14; Philippians 2:6-8, King James Version.Read the passagesJohn 1Philippians 2 ↩︎
Malachi 3:6, King James Version.Read the passagesMalachi 3 ↩︎
Hebrews 10:12, 14, King James Version.Read the passagesHebrews 10 ↩︎
